What is a Short Sale?
A short sale refers to a transaction when a buyer can purchase a home for less than the remaining loan
amount. The advantage is the buyer can save a significant amount on the purchase price, as long as the
buyer is willing to take part in a more complicated transaction. The transaction is more complicated
because it requires both the lender and the home owner to agree to the purchase price, as opposed to a
"normal" sale when the homeowner can make that decision on their own. This is because the lender
will receive less money from a short sale than they would have received if the homeowner paid the full
amount of the loan.
Who benefits from a Short Sale?
All parties involved in the transaction benefit. The lender benefits by avoiding the costs of foreclosing
on the property, which are often higher than taking the loss on the loan. The homeowner benefits by avoiding
a foreclosure, which can damage their credit history and raise the costs of borrowing money in the future.
The buyer benefits by purchasing the property at a discounted price, since the homeowner and lender are both
highly motivated sellers.
Where does a Buyer begin?
There are two things to keep in mind when thinking about doing a short sale. As the buyer, you need to
approach the homeowner to start the short sale process. This is because the majority of banks will agree
to a short sale only after the homeowner has received a formal offer. Also, make sure that there is a
pre-workout agreement between the lender and the homeowner. This agreement helps make sure the short sale
negotiations will go smoothly.
Requesting a Short Sale
First, locate a property where the debt of the homeowner is more than the amount the property can be sold
for. Approach the homeowner and make a formal offer on the property. Keep in mind a short sale can take
anywhere between 1-6 months to complete. There is a slew of documentation to submit before a short sale
can be approved. These documents generally include: a short sale application, tax returns, pay stubs, a
hardship letter, a purchase agreement from the buyer, financial statements, and payoff letters from all
lenders involved. After submitting the documentation, it generally takes 2-6 weeks to receive lender
feedback on the application. Don't be discouraged by the wait. Remember, the goal for the buyer is
to obtain property at a bargain-basement price.
Pre-Workout Agreements
Most lenders require a pre-workout agreement prior to starting workout negotiations. Pre-workout agreements
can take a variety of forms that range from a brief letter to a detailed contract that lays the foundation
for future negotiations between the defaulting borrower and the lender. A well-written agreement establishes
the history of the loan and the procedure for negotiating the short sale. It protects the borrower by
preventing the lender from foreclosing on the property during the workout and allows the lender to avoid
potential lender liability claims and defenses against their right to foreclose.
Tips for the Buyer
- Use a Real Estate Agent experienced in short sales.
- Do your homework before making an offer. Check public records. Find out who is on the title, how much is owed to the lender (to figure out how much to offer for the property) and if a foreclosure notice has already been filed (a short sale can only happen at the pre-foreclosure stage).
- Make sure you know how many loans are on the property. Avoid properties with more than one loan.
- Search for properties where the price is too low for the neighborhood, the property may already be in the short sale process.
- Make sure both the lender and the seller agree to your purchase offer. Both parties must agree in order for the short sale to go through. Have your agent submit the required documentation for approval.
- Get the appropriate contact for the lender and give them a deadline to respond to make sure your paperwork is processed in a timely manner.
- Ask your agent to waive the difference in commission between the buyer's broker agreement and the lender negotiated commission.
- Make sure the lender allows you to conduct the necessary home inspections before you purchase the property.
Short Sales and Today's Mortgage Crisis
Today's mortgage crisis is leading to an increase in the number of short sales and presenting wonderful
buying opportunities for the willing buyer. Declining home values are causing a huge drop off in home
equity (the property's market value minus the loan amount) and homeowners are struggling to meet their
monthly payments due to mortgage interest rate hikes. Distressed homeowners are no longer able to refinance
their way out of unmanageable loans. We are seeing historically high foreclosure rates across the country
due to eroding home values and problems in the credit markets.
The Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act was recently passed by the federal government to help address this
growing problem. Prior to its passage, the amount forgiven in a short sale was reported as taxable income.
Now, distressed homeowners don't need to worry about income tax liabilities when considering short sales.
This legislation is leading more people to take the short sale route and as a result, providing the buyer
with a larger pool of discounted properties to choose from.
Conclusion
"There is no sign that we're near the bottom in the housing market," states Douglas
Elmendorf, a senior fellow at Brookings Institution and a Former Fed economist. Housing prices are
predicted to fall in the next few years and short sales will continue to play a significant role in
the real estate market. This is a great opportunity for a buyer to purchase discounted property and
at the same time help a distressed homeowner save their credit history.